Looks like Andy Cohen’s advice didn’t stop Alicia Carmody from making a big decision.
After “The Real Housewives of Rhode Island” reunion ended with fiancé Billy Kitsilis handing Alicia paperwork that would make her a 50 percent owner of Pizza Mamma, fans were left wondering whether she actually signed the documents.
Now, it appears they have their answer.
In a recent Instagram post, Alicia shared a celebratory video outside Pizza Mamma while sipping champagne and opening a pizza box. Alongside the clip, she wrote, “This and owning 50%,” while tagging the restaurant.
The post strongly suggests that Alicia officially signed the paperwork and is now a co-owner of the business she spent much of season 1 helping build.
The ownership debate became one of the biggest storylines on “The Real Housewives of Rhode Island” after Alicia repeatedly expressed frustration that her name wasn’t included on the restaurant despite her role in creating it.
At the reunion, Billy surprised Alicia by bringing paperwork that would make her a 50 percent owner of Pizza Mamma. He joked that she’d get her half of the business if she agreed to drive their daughter to dance class several times a week.
Alicia wasn’t ready to sign on the spot, even as several of her castmates encouraged her to do it. Andy Cohen, however, advised her to take the paperwork home and read through everything before making such a big decision.
The RHORI Star’s Pizza Rules Are Just as Strong as Ever
Alicia may have earned the nickname “flip-flopper” on “The Real Housewives of Rhode Island,” but when it comes to pizza, she’s not changing her mind.
During an interview with Delish while promoting Baileys’ new Chocolate Minis, Alicia shared some of her strongest opinions about the perfect slice. For starters, she said pizza should always be cooked well done.
“If I get a pizza, it has to be well done,” she said, explaining that she prefers a thin, crispy pie with light cheese and very little sauce—what she jokingly called “a cracker pizza.”
That preference unexpectedly became one of her most memorable moments during season 1. Alicia admitted she never imagined viewers would latch onto her love of crackers.
“They loved the freaking crackers,” she said. “I had no clue, I swear to God, that crackers would take [off].”
She also made it clear there’s one pizza topping she simply won’t entertain.
“Asking for ranch? For pizza?” Alicia said. “I never heard of that. I don’t do ranch. Not my thing. Next.”
The reality star also revealed a few other pizza rules she lives by, saying she always eats the crust and would never reheat a slice in the microwave, preferring the oven or toaster instead.
RHORI season 1 is available to stream on Peacock.
Want even juicier Bravo tea? Sign up for Cocktail Party here.
