Amanda Batula is no longer brushing off the rumors.
During season 10, episode 3 of “Summer House,” Amanda had a candid conversation with a producer about ongoing speculation surrounding husband Kyle Cooke’s loyalty. The episode, filmed months before the couple publicly confirmed their separation (although Cocktailers know when they REALLY split), showed tension simmering beneath the surface.
And now, fresh insider claims are adding fuel to the Bravo gossip fire.
Amanda Batula Admits She’s Unsure About Kyle Cooke Rumors
While rehashing a recent argument on the beach, Kyle reminded Amanda that she knew he was a “social person” before they got engaged and married.
Her reply was direct: “But I didn’t think ‘social person’ meant cheating.”
The episode included a flashback to Kyle’s admitted infidelity from years earlier, reminding viewers of the couple’s complicated history.
Amanda to Kyle: "Me not going out with you shouldn't change your faithfulness to me and how intoxicated you get when you get out."#SummerHouse pic.twitter.com/Itw2hGosBV
— Jamie Steinberg ♡ (@NotYerAvgChick) February 18, 2026
Amanda also revealed that she regularly receives direct messages about Kyle’s behavior.
“Every time you go out, I get DMs telling me that you were up to something suspicious,” Amanda said. “And I don’t even bring them all up to you anymore, because it’s just constant.”
In a confessional, a producer asked Amanda point-blank whether she believed Kyle had cheated on her again.
“I don’t know,” she responded. “I’d like to think not, but he has in the past. And I know that there have been plenty of rumors about it, so who knows? Only Kyle.”
Insiders Allege 2023 Kyle Cooke Minnesota Makeout Incident
Following the episode, two sources came forward with claims about Kyle’s alleged behavior in Minnesota in June 2023.
The Bravo Investigator’s Dana Regan shared a February 18 Instagram post referencing an unverified blind item.
“I hate to do this … but it is my job to spill the tea. The blind item is not verified,” Dana wrote.
One source claimed, “I know he did! Saw him at a bar in MN making out with someone, completely hammered. But you didn’t hear it from me.”
A second insider said Kyle was in Ramsey, Minnesota, for the Johnsonville SuperHole IV celebrity cornhole tournament on June 23, 2023, at the Adrenaline Sports Center.
Amanda to Kyle – “I need you to get your drinking under control”
Kyle – *DRINKS*
Clearly Kyle chooses the drink over his marriage and then to accuse Amanda of “driving me to drink”
The DISRESPECT is wild! #SummerHouse pic.twitter.com/t6sTVsFgvU
— Dustin Cone (@Dustin_Cone) February 18, 2026
“1000 percent! He was in town for a celebrity cornhole tournament. I didn’t watch Summer House at the time but my friend told me he was married and he was making out with some chick who was clearly a fan,” the source alleged. “I mean, he was suuuuuuuper drunk.”
The insider added that Kyle appeared different the following day.
“We ended up chit-chatting the next day at the same bar when he was more sober … and he seemed completely different sober.”
According to the same source, Olympic swimmer Ryan Lochte was present at the event. Photos later shared by Dana showed Kyle seated between Ryan and actor Scott Porter at the competition.
As of now, the claims remain unverified. “Summer House” season 10 drops new episodes Tuesdays on Bravo.
Want even juicier Bravo tea? Sign up for Cocktail Party here
Her saying him being social shouldn’t have any bearing on his loyalty to her… chef’s kiss Amanda! I am so over this man and his abusive a$$ outbursts. He told his wife she had no personality last week! What does he say to her when cameras aren’t around? What we saw in the “apology dunes” was straight up abuse. It’s really hard to watch.
Kyle needs to stop drinking. The sooner he realises this the better his life will be.