Sipping cocktails.    Spilling tea.

A D-List Reality Star Tried to Insert Himself Into Lindsay Hubbard’s Story

by | Nov 30, 2025, 11:20 AM | Too Hot for IG | 7 comments

Summer House star Lindsay Hubbard during an appearance on WWHL

Can’t wait to see Lindsay Hubbard get activated over this one….

Someone posted an interview of Johnny Bananas (real world / the challenge) in Kate Casey’s FB group- sounded like a podcast episode, maybe? Had no idea who the guy interviewing him was.

Well, we all know he hooked up with Lindsay in the past (Summer House).

Johnny Bananas is claiming when they were hanging out after she split from Carl-they had “relations” close enough to when she announced she was pregnant that he was worried it was his.. which we knew that she got pregnant soon after dating her baby daddy.

He said when she announced she was pregnant, he was waiting for a phone call from her that it was his. Obviously, that call never came…

Want even juicier Bravo tea? Sign up for Cocktail Party here.

‘Summer House’ in September!

About Amanda

Amanda is a co-founder of Bravo and Cocktails and co-hosts the Cocktails and Gossip podcast with B, the Prosecco Princess. With a long career in marketing and advertising — and an even longer one as a reality TV fan — Amanda has been hooked since the genre began with The Real World. She grew up devouring blogs like The Awful Truth on E! and Perez Hilton, and treating herself to People and Us Weekly at the checkout line. These days, you can find her cheering on her kids from the sidelines, traveling, checking out new restaurants, and of course, watching TV with her husband. Amanda is also the person behind the scenes at Cocktail Party — if you have questions about the site or your membership, feel free to send her a note at amanda@bravoandcocktails.com.

Related posts:

A Lindsay Hubbard spinoff is reportedly happeningLindsay Hubbard Claps Back at Johnny Bananas Over ‘Baby Daddy’ Claim Summer House Season 9 cast posing on the BeachSummer House Season 10: Who’s In and Who’s Out and What We’ve Heard The Summer House season 10 cast has been spotted filmingSummer House Cast Spotted! In the City stars Lindsay Hubbard and Kyle CookeSummer in the City Cast!!!!
Previous Post
Next Post

7 Comments

  1. Lisa
    Lisa on 11/30/2025 at 11:58 am

    Still could be his? Maybe? 🫣🤔

  3. Amie
    Amie on 11/30/2025 at 12:10 pm

    Gross. Some things you can keep to yourself you thirsty loser fool.

  5. Kaitlyn
    Kaitlyn on 11/30/2025 at 12:58 pm

    This is gross and rumoring about the paternity of a child’s father isn’t gossip

  6. Elizabeth
    Elizabeth on 11/30/2025 at 3:17 pm

    Classy guy

  7. Angela
    Angela on 11/30/2025 at 8:15 pm

    I am guessing and mind you it’s pure speculation that someone with Turner’s money, not being married to the mother, in order to protect the money there would have been a paternity test done early on.

  8. Kelly
    Kelly on 11/30/2025 at 8:54 pm

    Doesn’t surprise me, she wanted a baby. She didn’t care how she got it.

  9. Jennifer
    Jennifer on 12/01/2025 at 7:38 am

    No shame to her, but math wise I think she got pregnant extremely early on in just being an hookup and then they tried to make a relationship work after the fact.