The timeline of Amanda Batula and West Wilson’s controversial romance is already under fire following part one of the “Summer House” season 10 reunion.
During Tuesday night’s reunion premiere, Amanda and West attempted to explain exactly when their relationship became romantic, insisting that their first kiss occurred at the end of February after a cast brunch and claiming they did not become intimate until after they released their joint relationship statement on March 31.
But Bravo fans — and apparently multiple insiders — are now questioning whether the timeline fully adds up.
Amanda Batula & West Wilson’s Timeline Is Being Challenged
Shortly after the reunion aired, several social media accounts began resurfacing old sightings and anonymous tips that seemed to contradict Amanda and West’s version of events.
Laguna Biotch pointed out on Threads that a tip about Amanda and West allegedly “canoodling” at a New York City bar had already been submitted on February 23.
“West and Amanda are fully canoodling!! He’s got her straddled and he’s rubbing her legs!” the original tip allegedly claimed.
Another insider later alleged the pair were spotted making out at West’s apartment on March 14 — weeks before their public statement confirming the relationship.
Adding even more fuel to the speculation, Deuxmoi referenced leaked reunion audio tied to a mysterious video Amanda and West allegedly discussed during filming.
According to the account, Amanda reportedly admitted the video captured her in a “vulnerable, intimate” moment before their March 31 statement was released.
Fans immediately began questioning whether Amanda and West’s reunion explanation about when they became intimate was entirely truthful.
Meanwhile, the couple appears completely unbothered overseas.
Amanda Batula & West Wilson Continue Italy PDA Tour
Amanda and West were photographed throughout Rome after quietly leaving the country just as reunion episodes began airing.
Our insiders told us the pair were spotted showing major PDA at a pub in Rome’s Monti neighborhood.
“West [and] Amanda spotted at a pub in Monti, Rome. They were heavy on the PDA, kissing every [five minutes],” the insider claimed.
The couple was also photographed walking through the streets of Rome together.
However, West seemingly addressed the trip during a recent episode of his “Show Me Something” podcast, where he confirmed he had a family wedding to attend.
“I have a wedding I leave for later today,” West shared on May 25.
The comment appeared to shut down speculation that the pair fled the country solely to avoid backlash from the reunion.
Kyle Cooke & Castmates Continue Questioning Relationship Timeline
Before the reunion even began, Amanda’s estranged husband, Kyle Cooke, openly questioned when the relationship between Amanda and West actually started.
During the premiere episode of In the City, Kyle discussed the situation with several cast members after Amanda and West publicly confirmed their romance.
“Amanda tried to play it off last night like it’s only been happening for a month,” Kyle claimed.
Mia Calabrese also called “bulls–t” on the timeline and alleged Amanda and West had been together “at minimum” since January.
Kyle went even further, suggesting rumors had circulated for nearly a year.
“I will say there were [blind items] going back to June 2025,” he alleged.
“I don’t know what Amanda and West can say to, like, recover.”
During the reunion itself, West explained that he first realized there could be romantic feelings between them after looking at Amanda during a brunch outing.
“I was like, ‘Am I f–kin’ crazy, or is there a little something going on here?’” he recalled.
Amanda later confirmed they slept together sometime after their public statement.
“After the statement,” she clarified. “I mean, not that night, but…”
Part two of the “Summer House” season 10 reunion airs Tuesday, June 2, on Bravo.
Want even juicier Bravo tea? Sign up for Cocktail Party here.
Related posts:
Amanda Batula and West Wilson Keep NYC Date Nights Going After Romance Reveal
‘Summer House’ Stars Amanda Batula and West Wilson’s Full Relationship Timeline Includes Kyle Cooke Split, Ciara Miller Fallout and Reunion Chaos
Amanda Batula and West Wilson’s Italy Trip Has a Much Bigger Backstory
About the Girl Filming With the ‘Summer House’ Crew!!